More about Shadowing
It can be frustrating to researchers, as they sometimes need to probe for more detail based on what they learn in shadowing exercises. But, at the same time, shadowing can help validate the participant’s journey. Shadowing also gives a quick insight into the design context for an audience, quickly and accurately.
Shadowing can be done for as short as 30 minutes to a few weeks or months depending on what the design researcher wishes to learn from the exercise.
Shadowing is a useful behavioral observation tool where users can be observed in their natural environment. However, researchers shouldn’t make assumptions based on the findings of single isolated observations. Additionally, results should not be considered a representation of the whole population either.
Types of Shadowing
Generally, there are three types of shadowing: natural (no-interference) – where the design researcher only observes the research subject for a set period without interference; controlled – where the researcher designs a task and observes it being carried out; and participatory – where the researcher performs the activity being observed to gain a firsthand perspective. The descriptions of each of these methods are briefly explained in the following table with their purpose, advantages and disadvantages.
Method
Purpose
Advantages
Disadvantages
Natural (no-interference)
To observe the natural way of performing a specific activity.
- Lends the users more flexibility.
- Chances of identifying criticalities are higher.
Different research subjects can perform the same activity differently which can add complexity when consolidating different journeys into one.
Controlled
Get Insight into a specific journey.
It is an observational probing technique for the researcher as they can control the steps to follow when performing an activity.
The users have lesser flexibility in performing the activity. Those users who do not perform the activity in the manner designed by the researcher may not contribute significantly to research if the outlined steps feel clumsy.
Participatory
Gain a firsthand perspective
- Gives the researcher a chance to see things from the users perspective.
- Can lead to developing greater empathy as well as a great rapport between the researcher and participant.
- May affect the natural journey of the participant.
Can lead to research subject and researcher bias.
Advantages of Shadowing
1. Real-time data collection
Shadowing is a very effective and real-time data collection method in research.
2. Rich behavioral insight
As the researcher observes user behavior firsthand or experiences it, it leads to rich and meaningful insights, which would have otherwise gone undiscovered
3. User centered
A greater stress is laid on the user than the product or service
4. Greater Empathy
Can create a greater empathy for the user in the researcher.
Disadvantages of Shadowing
1. Time-consuming
As individual participants perform or simulate a trail, the time taken for shadowing is high per user.
2. Complex Analysis
As all users may have their own way of performing an action, the data collection, organization and specifically analysis is more complex than other methods.